Index updates: dated reviews of the AI detector data

An update is a dated page that says what changed in the index over a stated period, in the same fields the cards and records use: cards added, study records added, figures that moved on a card, rankings whose order changed, and corrections filed. The first update is the 2026 review of every published false positive figure, written on 9 November 2026 at index version 2026.11.3, followed the same day by the Q4 2026 index update and studies digest at version 2026.11.13, with 72 cards and 35 study records in the index. Quarterly updates continue from the first quarter of 2027, one on the index data and one on the studies added, and an annual review closes each year. Every update carries a register ID in the AIDI-UP series, a year in its slug because it is a dated item, and a revision log of its own.

The pages here are not news. A vendor's launch post, a price change or a renamed brand is recorded on the card the day it is read, with the source and the date, and the corrections log carries the dated line; an update gathers those lines over a period and sets them against the study records, so a reader can see in one place whether the evidence moved with the claims. The 2026 false positive review, for example, lists the 28 rows of false positive figures the 35 records print for twelve of the 72 detectors, from 0 of 40 human papers for four tools in Van Vlasselaer 2026 (DOI 10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w) to a 0.9503 rate for the RoBERTa-base baseline in Jabarian and Imas 2025 (NBER w34223), both read 9 November 2026, and then records that Pangram moved from the vendor table into the false positive rate ranking on the strength of the second paper.

An update is built from the index data file and the study records, and from nothing else. Where a figure on an update differs from the figure on a card, the card is wrong or the update is, and the correction is made on both the day it is confirmed. Counts on an update are the counts at the version named in its first paragraph, so a 2026 review that says twelve detectors have study-sourced false positive data is a statement about version 2026.11.13, and the next review will carry its own version and its own count. The methodology page holds the rules an update follows; the studies index holds every record an update cites; and the home board shows the AI detector index the updates describe.

Readers use the updates in two ways. A procurement team re-reading a shortlist a year after writing it can take the annual review and see which figures on its cards came from a 2023 paper on 18 documents and which from a 2025 paper on 1,992 passages, and whether a 2026 study has since tested the tool on long papers. An editor or a journalist quoting a false positive rate can take the table row, which names the study, the base, the threshold and the date in one line, and quote it whole. Each update ends with three questions answered in their first clause and a Sources list with the read date of every URL.

The table below lists every update with its register ID, the year it reviews, and how many cards, records and questions it covers. The list grows by two each quarter and one each year; nothing is removed, and a superseded update keeps its page with a line pointing to the one that followed.

The twelfth wave on 10 November 2026 closed the year with three pieces: the 2027 census, the annual census that counts the cards, the gone, the tested, the open and the held, with the study index by year and kind; the Q3 2027 index update, covering 21 cards, two fields and two held rows across the tenth, eleventh and twelfth waves; and the Q3 2027 studies digest, the five records added with their figures and bases. The census is the annual piece for 2027 beside the 2026 false positive evidence review.

How an update is written

Every update, the same fields

Updated

Every dated update to the index, with the cards and records each one covers
Register IDUpdateYearCards citedRecords citedQuestions answered
AIDI-UP-012026 review: every published AI detector false positive figure in the indexEvery false positive figure the 17 indexed studies print for the 22 detectors, in one table with study, base, threshold and date, and what changed since launch.2026023
AIDI-UP-02Index update, Q4 2026: twelve cards added, five fields added, four corrections filedWhat changed in the AI detector index from version 2026.11 on 8 November 2026 to 2026.11.4 on 9 November: 12 cards, 5 rank fields, 9 records, every log line.2026003
AIDI-UP-03Studies digest, Q4 2026: the nine evaluations added since launch, with one headline figure eachThe nine AI detector studies indexed on 8 and 9 November 2026, from Chaka 2023 to the NIST pilot and Van Vlasselaer 2026, with headline figure, base and cards.2026513
AIDI-UP-04Index update, Q1 2027: fourteen cards added, four fields added, four rankings added, three log linesWhat changed in the AI detector index from version 2026.11.4 to 2026.11.7 on 9 November 2026: 14 cards, 4 rank fields, 4 rankings, 13 records, every log line.2027003
AIDI-UP-05Studies digest, Q1 2027: the thirteen evaluations added since the Q4 digest, with one headline figure eachThe 13 AI detector studies indexed on 9 November 2026 after the Q4 digest, from Pegoraro 2023 to Epoch AI 2026 and three challenge records, figure and base.2027403
AIDI-UP-06Index update, Q2 2027: nine cards added, nine fields added, one card held, three log linesWhat changed in the AI detector index from version 2026.11.7 to 2026.11.10 on 9 and 10 November 2026: 9 cards, 9 fields, 5 rankings, 1 held card, 3 log lines.2027043
AIDI-UP-07Studies digest, Q2 2027: no record added, seven records gained a card, two records still heldThe studies index held at 35 records in Q2 2027: no paper added, 7 records gained a card row for 4 new detectors, 2 closed-access papers held, revisions only.2027083
AIDI-UP-08AI detector census 2027: how many detectors the index holds, how many are gone, and how many have ever been tested72 AI detectors carded, 12 withdrawn, unreachable or redirected, 35 with a study record, 8 open source, 4 rows held: each count from the data, 10 November 2026.2027015
AIDI-UP-09Index update, Q3 2027: twenty-one cards added, two fields added, two rows held, three log linesWhat changed in the AI detector index from version 2026.11.10 to 2026.11.13 on 10 November 2026: 21 cards, 2 fields, 1 ranking, 5 views, 2 held rows, 3 lines.2027323
AIDI-UP-10Studies digest, Q3 2027: five records added, one headline figure and base each, two closed-access papers still heldThe studies index grew to 35 records in Q3 2027: Rashidi 2023, ASVspoof 2021, ADD 2023, FaceForensics++ 2019 and a vendor compilation, with figures and bases.20270113

Where do the updates start?

Questions about the index updates

How often is the index updated?

Cards are rechecked monthly, the next pass on 8 December 2026, and a figure that changes is corrected the day it is confirmed and logged in the corrections log. Updates gather those changes: two each quarter, on the data and on the studies, beginning with the Q4 2026 pair written on 9 November 2026, and one annual review.

What is in an update that is not already on the cards?

Nothing new in the figures: every number on an update is on a card or a record with the same source and date. The update adds the period view, which cards and records were added, which figures and rankings moved and when, and the single table that sets every figure of one kind, such as false positive rates, side by side.

Why does an update carry a year in its address when other pages do not?

Because an update is a dated item about a stated period, like a study record, and the year is part of what it is. Cards, rankings, views and question pages describe the index as it stands and change in place, so their addresses carry no year and their Updated line carries the date.

Related reading